Checklists approach Systematic approach
1

Thoroughness

Limited to the number of checklist that you get.

Unlimited

2

Specificity

Checklists are specific to certain scenario. e.g RLQ pain in 21 years old female.

What if it is 51 years old female?

100% non specific approach that covers ANY scenario checklist.

3

Practice time

Time consuming. Practicing several times, one for each checklist.

ONLY ONCE. Covers any checklist.

4

Shows check points

Visibly for specific scenario.

Indirectly covered for any scenario checklist.

5

Need to figure out how to ask

YES: Gives you the points that you'll have to figure out how to ask in a second preparatory step.

No: Gives the next step: questions in a dialogue format that covers the checklist. with correct communication skills.

6

logically organized

No. Jumping between data gathering sections. e.g CC Then PMHx or FHx then back and forth confusing the patient and the examiner. Easily forget important  points.

Yes. Smooth Step By Step System.

7

Time efficient

Only if the exact scenario came.

Always.

8

Communication skills

NONE.

Yes, impeded indirectly in the way the questions and comments are phrased and organized.

9

Medical jargon

YES, in many circulating checklists and FAMOUS websites.

Never.

10

Shows you how to prepare your medical knowledge

Not for any scenario.

Yes.

11

Shows you how to counsel.

Some

Shows how to organize it. What and how much information you need to prepare yourself to tell the patient.

12

Physical exam

Points only with long videos that you have to figure out how to do it in just 5 minutes!

A Time efficient organized system of how and what to examine for ALL scenarios.

13

Develop confidence in your clinical skills  & communication skills

No. Only if the same exact scenarios came.

Yes. You are assured that you can handle any OSCE Exam station..

14

Time limited access

All

No, yours for ever. You'll needed for future OSCEs and clinical practice.

15

Printing

Most, no.

OSCEhome: Yes.

16

Always needs a computer and internet for access

Yes. i.e limited places to study.

Only first time.

17

Will it help in your future OSCE Exams?

Yes but not much.

Definitely. You will be able to cover any complaint.

18

Will it help in your future medical practice?

Not much.

Definitely. You will be able to cover any complaint.

Assured of your communication skills.