| Checklists approach | Systematic approach | ||
| 1 |
Thoroughness |
Limited to the number of checklist that you get. |
Unlimited |
| 2 |
Specificity |
Checklists are specific to certain scenario. e.g RLQ pain in 21 years old female. What if it is 51 years old female? |
100% non specific approach that covers ANY scenario checklist. |
| 3 |
Practice time |
Time consuming. Practicing several times, one for each checklist. |
ONLY ONCE. Covers any checklist. |
| 4 |
Shows check points |
Visibly for specific scenario. |
Indirectly covered for any scenario checklist. |
| 5 |
Need to figure out how to ask |
YES: Gives you the points that you'll have to figure out how to ask in a second preparatory step. |
No: Gives the next step: questions in a dialogue format that covers the checklist. with correct communication skills. |
| 6 |
logically organized |
No. Jumping between data gathering sections. e.g CC Then PMHx or FHx then back and forth confusing the patient and the examiner. Easily forget important points. |
Yes. Smooth Step By Step System. |
| 7 |
Time efficient |
Only if the exact scenario came. |
Always. |
| 8 |
Communication skills |
NONE. |
Yes, impeded indirectly in the way the questions and comments are phrased and organized. |
| 9 |
Medical jargon |
YES, in many circulating checklists and FAMOUS websites. |
Never. |
| 10 |
Shows you how to prepare your medical knowledge |
Not for any scenario. |
Yes. |
| 11 |
Shows you how to counsel. |
Some |
Shows how to organize it. What and how much information you need to prepare yourself to tell the patient. |
| 12 |
Physical exam |
Points only with long videos that you have to figure out how to do it in just 5 minutes! |
A Time efficient organized system of how and what to examine for ALL scenarios. |
| 13 |
Develop confidence in your clinical skills & communication skills |
No. Only if the same exact scenarios came. |
Yes. You are assured that you can handle any OSCE Exam station.. |
| 14 |
Time limited access |
All |
No, yours for ever. You'll needed for future OSCEs and clinical practice. |
| 15 |
Printing |
Most, no. |
OSCEhome: Yes. |
| 16 |
Always needs a computer and internet for access |
Yes. i.e limited places to study. |
Only first time. |
| 17 |
Will it help in your future OSCE Exams? |
Yes but not much. |
Definitely. You will be able to cover any complaint. |
| 18 |
Will it help in your future medical practice? |
Not much. |
Definitely. You will be able to cover any complaint. Assured of your communication skills. |